{"text_format":"3","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":12,"sheets":["Inh","K","admin state","Warming","Adv 3","Solvency","Off 2","Off 3","Off 4","Off 5","Off 6","Macros"],"not_rendered":{"macros":1,"defined_names":11},"read":"whole","date_system":"1904"}

{"sheet":"Inh","index":0,"n_rows":1,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":1}
["1AC",null,"1NC","2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]

{"sheet":"K","index":1,"n_rows":102,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":102}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
["The aff is a fantasy of institutional rescue that furthers the politics of decency – their uncritical investment in the western juridical regime traps them within a schema of intelligibility that enshrines civility as a global decorum – their intervention props up white supremacist, cisheteropatriarchal, neoliberal mechanisms of carnage in the name of progress – only a politics of indecency premised on a total abolition of these state forms can create alternative worlds"]
["Their state-centric environmentalism re-invests faith in modernity and liberal subjecthood---that sustains racialized violence and makes ecological collapse inevitable.",1]
["Solving climate change for brown people is colonialist – it captures the agency of the global south through claims of ‘responsibility’ that only prop up the technostrategic godhood narrative of the white man.",null,null,"aff decency-liberal civitiy-state management"]
["Their focus on the particularities of executive authority furthers necropolitical decency by generating legitimacy for the global coloniality of power – genuine alternatives must target the infrastructure of the colonial state",null,null,"state can't stop own violence"]
["The political motivations for CCS ensure their solution to warming is grounded in a violent capitalist ontology that calcify extractive processes of neoliberalism that guarantee the militarization of the environment via technocracy",null,null,"usfg permanenet infra of necropoltiics-exterminitiaon of indgienous people, upgrade its function-theyshor up new nodes of violence. Sacrifice, biopolticail population, machinery of permant warfare. Mere existence ofs tate power justifies colonialition of mode of survival. List of example countries. "]
["Geoengineering is parasitic on indigenous sociality- any discussion of environmental redress must begin by resisting colonial domination ",null,null,"state enforces bad isms"]
["Vote negative to refuse to acquiesce to the 1AC’s internalization of decency and colonial governmentality – academic pursuits premised on reforming empire succumb to colonial ruses of power and are paid for in blood – only recognizing the molecular potential for abolition all around us stands a chance of averting extinction",null,null,"they will invade countries who don’t adopt ccs. Military destroys environment, global diffusion coloniali implementtion"]
[{"$nulls":3},"false legitimacy--masks resource xtraction"]
[{"$nulls":3},"state patronage of pollution"]
[{"$nulls":3},"disparate impact"]
[{"$nulls":3},"they result in solving terminal impact of warming--they don't resolve the factors that lead into that pollutio, militarism etc"]
[{"$nulls":3},"they solve it at global but not local?"]
[{"$nulls":3},"administrative agencies antagonistic to minority population, fantasy of lvieabiltiy--existnetial threats diffuse movements"]
[{"$nulls":3},"try or die for a complete break"]
[{"$nulls":3},"aff and perm are small concessions-card"]
[]
[null,null,"1. They should have to win that the aff is on-balance a bad idea compared to a hypothetical alternative","mode of subjectivity-politics of decency"]
[null,null,"a. Fairness – anything else shifts the debate ex post facto and eliminates 9 minutes of 1ac offense","comes first-schema inteligeibiltiy--prior questions, limits radicality"]
[null,null,"b. Clash – they justify critique of every possible assumption of the affirmative undermine substantive comparison of political strategies","internalize social norms that are bad, engaging onself before the law--settler legal persohood-dneied to others"]
[null,null,"c. Consequentialism is the only coherent framework for evaluation – focus on the efficacy of strategies is critical to developing effective praxis – you can’t determine if the alternative is ethical without assessing the implications of adopting that approach to the world – reject moral purity and default to util","desire for respability that is on minoriy populations"]
[null,null,"isaac 2k2","shapes fw procedure"]
[null,null,"d. Weak ontological claims are good - self reflexive acknowledgement of intellectual uncertainty is necessary to avoid academic dogmatism – interrogating issues from a variety of oppositional viewpoints attains a more complete picture of how to develop effective resistance – that also means you should reject totalizing explanations of how the world operates – that’s 1AC Nyman","only impact is subject, similar weight"]
[{"$nulls":3},"fw is poltiics of decency--no dapl, they got arrested, state miltiraze against indigenous demands"]
[{"$nulls":3},"fairness doesn't make sense--we can critiuq frmaing and jsutifcaitosn"]
[{"$nulls":3},"no capcity for spill up--live through the apocalphyse of the wolrd"]
[{"$nulls":3},"framew aff as the world model"]
[{"$nulls":3},"at weak ontology----weak ontology of set col, strict divide is erased, settler something, strong ontolgoical commitment or you are bad?"]
[{"$nulls":3},"yussoff-settler innocence--fantasy plan text and fiat ,disavow to settler elimination"]
[{"$nulls":3},"debating on stolen land"]
[{"$nulls":3},"linear process of genocide"]
[{"$nulls":3},"naturalize that process--admin state authority is worse"]
[{"$nulls":3},"they aren't conuslted on enviro mattes, flip the scales"]
[{"$nulls":3},"enemies of the state something"]
[{"$nulls":3},"technocracy link---vulenrable are data poitns--bare contium of life"]
[{"$nulls":3},"our shit is specific, centralization of power"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,"2. Alt cant solve\na. Warming– comprehensive studies prove only CCS technology can suck CO2 out of the atmosphere that prevents us from reaching catastrophic climactic tipping points – market mechanisms and government regulation are the ONLY method to create profit motives for CCS technology \n"]
[null,null,"tipping points"]
[null,null,"takes too long"]
[null,null,"renewables can only solev elctrict"]
[null,null,"cement and steal"]
[null,null,"alternative has to get rid of steal",{"$nulls":3},"warmign=extinction"]
[null,null,"investors don't care about climate policy",{"$nulls":3},"bad for other people"]
[{"$nulls":6},"give up on state action--unethical option possible--washing hands"]
[null,null,"b. Inequality – only administrative state capabilities allow for state based regulatory forcing that can create structural change to resolve inequality – regulations cause market reforms like minimum wage laws – their active ",{"$nulls":3},"state will lashout more with climate change"]
[null,null,"refusal alt is privatizaiton which magnifes the impact",{"$nulls":3},"ccs is the only method"]
[null,null,"Cant solve their impacts – movements get squashed which was proven by cx – they need to win that they TAKE DOWN THE STATE which they cant do ",{"$nulls":3},"extinction outweighs--irreevesiable"]
[{"$nulls":4},"dropped impact of warming-tipping point, negative emsisions",null,"no hope for value indigenous population"]
[{"$nulls":4},"climate change is bad",null,"inequality"]
[null,null,"3. privatee actor fiat-2ac skew, can't refute strat, no lit, outside resolution actor ","not fiating, our arg is reciprocal, fw is impact turn","resource shortage and resource wars",null,"divesting part of the state"]
[{"$nulls":3},"bracket out this radical shit","burden of proof","framework filter offense--advoacy spilling up ot instituitons--subjectivity and how they will interact with the advantages","permutation was dropped--ethicality of state"]
[{"$nulls":4},"life key to abolition","politcis of decency is bad--fair debate is genocidal of content","weak ontology approach-reject totalizing appraoch worlds"]
[{"$nulls":3},"1NR FLOW","people choose based off profit motive","should not be given fiat in the firat place","we don't have to be tied to all state action"]
[null,null,"Focus on technical legal constraints on the executive are key and the alt leads to autocracy\nScheppele\n 18","reading a 2nc card","some card about something","consequentalism--level of debate istself--discourse and speech acts","framework fairness"]
[{"$nulls":4},"inequality adv--1 in 3 deaths","paternalism link arguent--yasouf legitimacy of the stae, aff responds creates new legitimacy, death of everyone, apocalse moral fw enter the law or cede to extinction, legal subject or nobody, scapegoating","the 1ac is not genocidal"]
[{"$nulls":3},"ALTERNTIVE","private worse","actively erase the genocide of minnesota--involved in genocide","fiat double bind--justifiy it is a good idea"]
[null,null,"Climate catastrophism is the only method of motivating responses to climate change – their method results in tacit denialism and distances us from catastrophic effects – it forces confrontation of the effects of neoliberal excess which solves their links BUT only the affirmatives response has a prayer of solving","smal tinkering is bad","admin state should be protected-reforms good","settler moves of innocence","paternalism link--link turn--mckinnon justify genocide"]
[null,null,"latour","state existence is bad--cause their impacts","K FLOW","violent to indigenous people","tough shit go have fun dying"]
[{"$nulls":3},"disarticulate the state","specificty--demands on state itself, no totalizing","broader racialized scapegoating","ccs only prayer of life"]
[{"$nulls":3},"no one does anything--decency stifles dissent","no ev about invasion","fraser--engaging the law, detail and discourse, libraries, odel of legal personhood, full self possession depried to others, exclusive, trade off effect","scapegoating not supported by evidence"]
[null,null,"Forcing the state to confront climate risk ruptures politics of decency \nBeck, professor at the University of Munich and LSE, ‘14\n","affirmative a politics of decensy","state is key to ccs?","try or die--busbridge--since the state exists, linear process of genocide, landfall till now","permutation solves that"]
[{"$nulls":3},"prereq to complete overhaul of something??","passivity is bad","demonstrates inversion","state inev are an impact turn--no sufficiency solvency--links to squo"]
[{"$nulls":3},"commitment to decency is what makes it possible","some card about something","we don't have to solve these war arguments--they don't solve eath, the broader fiat double bind--10 years to spill up, timeframe da to resolve warming, accountability","conseuqentialism---moral purity isaac 2k2"]
[null,null,"The West MUST take responsibility for climate ethics through policy responses – their refusal to solve climate change IS ACTIVELY PROMOTING EXTINCTION FOR THE SAKE OF MORAL PURITY\nMackinnon ’18 ","indigenous direct action is better?","FW","extinction inev--egnagemnet modes of abolition live through the apocalypse","how does the alt get rid of colonial violence"]
[{"$nulls":3},"state backlash is the squo","debate is a game--ballot not political subjectiivy, refernedum on debate quality","FRAMEWORK","ethicality leads to state future"]
[{"$nulls":3},"don't have a card that makes it worse","consequences","ballot connected to mode of research we produce","state does plrenty of good things"]
[null,null,"perm do both--justification post capitalism future, interim steps","just about commitments/subjects to movements and their shit is bad","no neg offense disprove diesarability of the aff","primary link argument-colonial state existence"]
[{"$nulls":3},"they crowd out radical questioning","fiat double bind get out of here","impact urning scholarship"]
[{"$nulls":3},"state is genocial so they have to win a 100%","mode of legal engagement within 10 years","link turning consequentialism"]
[null,null,"Massive progress now by every metric, which DISPROVES the assumptions underpinning their impacts – But the alt’s institution- and progress-pessimism, ESPECIALLY in the face of collapse of the administrative state, shuts that ALL DOWN!! Proves you MUST REJECT their totalizing theory\nHorgan 16\n","state functioning itself is what causes warming not movemnet failure","alt can't scale up","ontology good--offshoot impact, settlers rerace own coplicity, pretend to be indigenous"]
[{"$nulls":3},"resource extraction struc violence","consequences--wash our hands, moral purity, catstrohic consequence","biaristic undestanding of native vs settler"]
[{"$nulls":3},"western comforto should come last","death ultimate evil","ALTERNATIVE"]
[null,null,"geo-e is not us--sulfur in environment","not a step in the right direction---card","weak ontology--no theory can explain everything","threshold flip--state functioning"]
[null,null,"no alt to solving",null,"not a forced choice","skepticis prove otheriws"]
[null,null,"no mech for post capital future","PERM",null,"they lock in inequality"]
[{"$nulls":3},"sever or intrinsic","ALTERNATIVE","perofrmative exmaple of solvency deficit-deceny as principle"]
[{"$nulls":3},"realm of civility-necropolitical death","can't solvewarming--state key to ccs","prioritize indigenous life"]
[null,null,"Framing settler colonialism through a totalizing lens of [absolute decolonization/incommensurability/etc] makes indigenous liberation impossible by setting the terms of victory as all-or-nothing—pessimism actively reifies settler dominance \nBusbridge 18\n","try or die for confronting","that doesn't guranatee the tech"]
[{"$nulls":4},"dapl didn't do shit"]
[{"$nulls":4},"movements didn't shit"]
[{"$nulls":4},"you can't stop army of lawyers"]
[{"$nulls":4},"state squash movements"]
[{"$nulls":4},"legal restarints are key--right wing fill in with lawyers"]
[{"$nulls":4},"dropped defense of progress--things are getting better, stats"]
[{"$nulls":4},"disproves state shit"]
[]
[{"$nulls":4},"perm--"]
[{"$nulls":4},"we call it into question via demands"]
[{"$nulls":4},"can agree with both"]
[{"$nulls":4},"mckinnon--west must take repsonsbiltiy, alt is ivory tower"]
[{"$nulls":4},"ccs does that"]
[{"$nulls":4},"try or die for technocracy"]
[]
[]
[{"$nulls":4},"busridge--consent arguments totalizing liberation, nuance native resitnce, contingency"]
[{"$nulls":4},"locks in violence--state remedying"]
[{"$nulls":4},"xxx"]

{"sheet":"admin state","index":2,"n_rows":9,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":9}
["1AC",null,"1NC","2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
["Recent court decisions limiting the applicability of the Chevron framework, the “step zero” test, usurps agency authority and guts the Chevron doctrine – State Farm review at step 2 solves"]
["Deference doctrine is at a critical juncture – continued step zero carveouts eliminate Chevron and the administrative state –hard look shifts the courts direction ",1]
["Chevron retreat collapses regulation and the administrative state in every area —Skidmore can’t solve"]
["Those deregulatory attacks undermine the foundation of administrative capabilities to combat all social, racial, and economic inequalities --- ",null,"Trump has flooded the judiciary at all levels – it’s hosed for decades\nMcCarthy 3/10 ","1. we fiat"]
["Inequality is responsible for one in three deaths.   \nBezruchka 14 ",null,null,"2. implemt judges properly"]
["Judges implement hard look review properly - comprehensive experimental studies demonstrate ideology minimally impacts decisions\nKahan ‘16\n",null,null,"3. not specific to aff"]
["Pragmatism centered on weak-ontological claims is the best process for political contestation ",null,"Hard-look review is already applied at Step Two—current deference regimes do not produce a structural or attitudinal barrier to the plan\nHammond 16\n","aff is inherent-sharp 18"]
["Face ecological risk head on –  latour 13"]

{"sheet":"Warming","index":3,"n_rows":16,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":16}
["1AC",null,"1NC","2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
["Chevron deference is divided into two steps – courts determine (1) whether the law is vague and (2) whether an agency’s interpretation of the law is reasonable – lax judicial review at Step Two lets agencies wantonly shift policies without justification"]
["The aff applies “hard look” scrutiny at Chevron Step Two, that restricts baseless shifts in policy – only vetted, well-reasoned rules receive deference"]
["The affs model ratchets up the stringency of review - "]
["The aff’s constraint on step two limits flip flopping and deregulation, but doesn’t sacrifice the Chevron framework"]
["Policy shifts undermine stability and innovation in regulated markets – applying strict review of policy justifications forces agencies to commit to regulations"]
["Specifically, regulatory certainty over long time horizons is key to CCS"]
["Now key – CCS requirements are on the books now, Trump is trying to roll them back and remove the basis for future CCS rules across the board – only the plan solves"]
["It’s feasible and close to commercial viability, aff solves – newest qualified study and pilot plants prove",null,"ccs fails","Status quo deference allows for regulatory flip flop – agencies can reverse on a dime which harms investment in regulated markets like CCS – the affs incorporation of judicial review prevents arbitrary flip flops absent comprehensive justifications ","foster--breakthrough instiutie, neoliberal violence, broader quick fix, takes out perm, nation states overshoot, suck carbon, magical thinking, moral hazard, turns warming, narrow conception of self interest, forms of struct vioelnce it stil causes cancner and radiation."]
["The tech exists for CCS – rapid scale up is key ",null,null,"Warming causes extinction – sea level rise, ocean acidification, and extreme weather guarantee interim conflict and resource grabs and make the planet uninhabitable - inaction causes genocide in coastal areas "]
["Carbon capture is the only feasible method of achieving emissions reductions targets – renewables and taxation are insufficient ",null,null,"Extinction outweighs – death is the ultimate evil that forecloses the possibility of finding any intersubjective understanding of value – extinction is  THE MOST unethical decision because it prevents any from finding value in the world "]
["The impacts to warming are linear - CCS is the only method of preventing catastrophic tipping points – all other options require impossible global societal transformation",null,null,"That turns the K – warming disproportionately affects coastal communities and causes violent resource power grabs because of shortages – the aff is the only possible method of resolving preventable violence and death"]
["Warming is existential – best models prove that bending the carbon curve is necessary and sufficient to stay below key tipping points ",null,null,"no warrant in ccs card"]
[{"$nulls":3},"begs question of storage capacity"]
[{"$nulls":3},"try or die"]
[{"$nulls":3},"We have the storage capacity to solve\nBurger et al., 16"]

{"sheet":"Adv 3","index":4,"n_rows":3,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":3}
["1AC",null,"1NC","2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
[]
[null,1]

{"sheet":"Solvency","index":5,"n_rows":1,"n_cols":8,"rows_kept":1}
["1AC",null,"1NC","2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]

{"sheet":"Off 2","index":6,"n_rows":1,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":1}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]

{"sheet":"Off 3","index":7,"n_rows":3,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":3}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
[]
[null,1]

{"sheet":"Off 4","index":8,"n_rows":3,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":3}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
[]
[null,1]

{"sheet":"Off 5","index":9,"n_rows":3,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":3}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
[]
[null,1]

{"sheet":"Off 6","index":10,"n_rows":3,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":3}
["1NC",null,"2AC","2NC","1AR","2NR","2AR"]
[]
[null,1]

{"sheet":"Macros","index":11,"n_rows":18,"n_cols":2,"rows_kept":18}
["Command","Function "]
["Control+Shift+N","Auto-Numbers"]
[]
["Control + I ","Add Row "]
[]
["control + b","Group Selection "]
[]
["control + shift + b","Undo Group Selection "]
[]
["Control + S ","New Sheet "]
[]
["Control + L ","5 spaces down "]
[]
["Control + K ","5 spaces up"]
[]
["Control + Pageup","Next Sheet to the left"]
[]
["Control + Pagedown ","Next Sheet to the Right "]